Since 16-year-old Kelby came out as a lesbian, she and her family have been treated as pariahs in their small town of Tuttle, Oklahoma. The one time all-star athlete, Kelby has faced an outpouring of hatred from classmates as well as teachers and has been forced to leave her basketball and softball team because of verbal abuse from her teammates. Refusing her parents' offer to leave Tuttle, the gutsy teenager is bolstered by her adoring girlfriend and a few staunch friends, resolving to stay. Even when she's run down and hit by a van full of high school boys while walking back from lunch, she believes it's her destiny to remain in this small conservative town - and change a few minds.